This post contains spoilers from Wednesday’s episode ofThe Masked Singer.
The Masked Singerhad a mega night on Wednesday.
Modern Family’sEric Stonestreetjoined panelistsKen Jeong,Jenny McCarthy,Nicole ScherzingerandRobin Thicketo help decipher who might be under the first group of contestants' costumes. The undercover celebrities recapped their first performance before taking the stage again, and after they sang, hostNick Cannonbrought out a mega clue for each star.
Team Good’s Firefly, whochoked last weekduring her first attempt at coveringChaka Kahn’s “Ain’t Nobody,” said she felt “so much pressure on my shoulders” ahead of her second performance. “In this business, the show must go on,” Firefly said.
Michael Becker/FOX
Firefly’s mega clue turned out to be a puzzle of a photo ofPharrell Williams. “Pharrell is one of the major keys of my career,” the glowing insect said.Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free weekly newsletterto get the biggest news of the week delivered to your inbox every Friday.
The judges thought Firefly could beAisha Tyler,Keyshia ColeorLauryn Hill.
Cyclops came up next to represent Team Bad. “Tonight I’m going to show the panel another side to my bad self,” the one-eyed creature said before performingElvis Presley’s “Suspicious Minds.”
Thicke, 45, called Cyclops an “unpredictable wildcard.”
“All I wanted to do is make it past the first week,” Cyclops said. “Now that I’ve done that, I’m here to have fun.”
The men in black delivered a meteorite that crashed in 1988 to the stage for Cyclops’s mega clue. “This meteorite was found in a nook in Ken’s backyard from a galaxy far, far away,” Cyclops explained.
Matchbox Twenty’sRob Thomasand actorsChris PrattandJohn Lithgowwere guesses for the mythological being.
Ram’s mega clue was an Emmy. “I’m gonna add this to my collection,” the towering male sheep said.
Jason Biggs, Ty Burrell andJason Sudeikiswere guesses for Ram — but Ram thought theAmerican Piestar wouldn’t be able to fill out his costume. Ram also received a message from celebrity BFF Kate Hudson, who told him, “I’m cheering you on.”
Team Cuddly’s Thingamabob closed out the night. “A lot of people think I’m big and scary,” Thingamabob said, “but tonight I’m going to show them my cuddly side.”
The men in black revealed Thingamabob’s mega clue to be two shields. “I left my trident backstage, but I still wanted to rock these shields to show America I’m ready for battle,” Thingamabob explained.
The judges suggested Thingamabob might be actors Omar Benson Miller,Jason MomoaorDwayne Johnson.
RELATED VIDEO: Duff Goldman Talks About How He Got Approached to Play an Instrument on The Masked Singer
Then it came time for the panel and studio audience to vote for their favorite performance of the night. The two with the fewest number of votes would face off in a duel. Cannon, 41, announced that Firefly and Ram would be the ones dueling — and Firefly did not take the news well. The Firefly walked off stage but ultimately did return to battle Ram.
That meant Ram would have to unmask.
Stonestreet, 50, and Thicke’s guess ofJoe Buckturned out to be correct, as the sports commentator, 52, appeared underneath the horned head.
Michael Becker/FOX; Bob Levey/Getty
The Masked Singerairs Wednesdays (8 p.m. ET) on Fox.
Dana Rose Falcone
source: people.com
